On Monday, in a now-deleted tweet, writer Hanna Rosen criticized Hulu’s popular new movie “Fire Island” for its so-called failed Bechdel test. Rosin wrote that the movie “got an F- on the Bechdel test in a whole new way. Are we ignoring the horrible lesbian stereotypes of BC cute gay Asian boys? Is this revenge for all those years of a gay best friend?”
By the next day, the tweet was gone and a whole new series of tweets appeared, with apologies. Rosen wrote: “My tweet was careless and reckless. truly. The movie was telling a story about queer AAPI [Asian American Pacific Islander] Guys, whose experiences don’t show enough in movies or anywhere else…what I had to say was off topic, not to mention stir up emotions in a fun summer movie. “
“Fun Summer” is written by its star, Joel Kim Poster, and focuses on the experiences of gay Asian men. Doing so is a rarity in Hollywood where the majority of stories are still told by straight people, especially white people. When the characters are gay, they are usually white. In 2019, GLAAD found that only 34% of queer characters were color characters, a small percentage that remained decreasedown from 42% the year before and 57% in 2017.
But Rosen focused in her tweet on the film’s lack of female characters and cited a long-standing measurement of women’s roles in cinema: the Bechdel Test. what or what he is The Bechdel test and what does the person named after him say about all this?
RELATED: How ‘Fire Island’ Puts Pride in ‘Pride and Prejudice’
Bechdel’s audition comes from the comedy “Dykes to Watch Out For” directed by Alison Bechdel, MacArthur Fellow and author of the graphic memoir “Fun Home,” which was turned into a 2015 Tony Award-winning musical. Bechdel and his friend Liz Wallace created the audition in 1985 (sometimes called the Bechdel-Wallace Test) when you tell another character that she goes to see a movie only if it features two female characters talking to each other about something other than the man.
Easier said than done. In the comics, only “Alien” meets these qualifications. bechdeltest.com has a database since 2013 of hit and miss movies. Recent films that fail to complete three components of the Bechdel test (two characters talking to each other, not just talking about a guy) according to the site include “Ambulance,” “Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore,” and “The Northman.”
Do you pass “Island of Fire”? we will . . . Hulu, a loose update of Jane Austen’s “Pride and Prejudice,” centers on a found family of gay friends determined to spend one last great summer on Fire Island, New York’s famous gay mecca. All friends are male except for one, Erin (Margaret Cho). Her role is neither the largest nor the most developed: Irene is older, not a partner and loses her home. The only other woman in the movie? Very slight, very angry lesbian on a boat.
But the film is a showcase for gay Asian men and those specific experiences that are largely absent from the popular imagination. The objection to a missing story does not take into account the other marginal stories it highlights. Dr. Medellin of The MarySue wrote: “Instead of being enthused about a major movie that provides a platform for a traditionally underrepresented ensemble, we get a hot shot of the school of white feminism that nobody asked for. White feminism has a long history of making arguments about inclusion or visibility only if… White women were specifically included.”
So, the short answer is no, it didn’t pass. However, it may be time to take various other measures. Valid criticism can be made of the film, including its portrayal black korean characters. But for the lack of women, it’s not about them. Actor and Producer Emerson Collins Tweet, ‘Fail ‘FI’ [the Bechdel test] rather on purpose. . . Gay Asian men rarely/never position themselves this way.”
The answer may be simple: we need more films. As Rebecca Sun writes, “Stories do not have to revolve around a single, historically excluded identity every one of them. “It is time for more different and varied stories about multiple types of underrepresented societies and experiences.
Want a daily wrap-up of all the salon news and reviews? Sign up for our morning newsletter, Crash Course.
exact answer? From the test author herself, Alison Bichdale, who tweeted: “Well, I just Added natural result To the Bechdel Test: Two men talk to each other about the female protagonist of the Alice Monroe story in a script based on Jane Austen’s novel = Scroll. the summer:
More stories like this